Left-wing ‘New Politics’ actually means self-righteous ‘Probity-ringers’ wallowing in cruelty and immorality
Original Article by Nick Cohen
Stereotypes aren’t always pernicious.
Left-wingers have benefitted for years from being typecast as decent people.
They may possesses the self-righteousness of “a teenager who had just become a vegetarian”, as Jess Phillips, the marvellous Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley, warned.
But like teenage vegetarians, they mean well.
If the world does not always turn out the way they planned, that is the world’s fault.
It would be a better place if it did as the left told it to, sat up at the table and ate its greens.
Stereotypical rightwingers could not be more different.
They are sexist, racist and hypocritical.
Tories are motivated by greed and prejudice.
The far right is driven by brutish blood lusts.
The hold of these stereotypes among the progressive, university-educated middle classes explains why you never hear a rightwing political comedian on Radio 4 or see a leftwing villain in a television drama.
Comics and writers tear into Daily Mail and Sun readers but never Guardian and Observer readers.
They assume that you are virtuous.
Police are investigating a death threat made against Neil Coyle, the Labour MP for Bermondsey, after he voted to allow the RAF to attack Islamic State in Syria.
His colleague Diana Johnson said the abuse of Labour MPs who supported the action was horrendous. “‘Murderous cunt’ is one of the terms I have seen.”
Now, as so often in the past, the similarities between the far left and far right are more striking than the differences.
Coyle received death threats from the far left for supporting war against Isis.
Phillips received rape threats from the far right after she mocked the idea that Britain needed an international men’s day so “their voices could be heard”.
Paula Sherriff, the Labour MP for Dewsbury, was treated no better.
She made an appeal for unity between communities after a local teenager left to murder for Isis.
Detectives intervened because a local racist left a message on her Facebook page that read: “Dead girl walking. Hope you get raped. We got your phone number and details. Thanks.”
Death threats, rape threats – choose your extreme and take your pick.
Meanwhile, Corbyn has ensured that everything the left once said about mainstream conservatives can be thrown back its face.
You want sexism? Long before the Syria vote, Liz Kendall and Yvette Cooper complained of misogyny, and not just from the Mail, which was more interested in Kendall’s “lithe figure” than her politics.
You expect that from the Mail if you are a woman on the left.
Indeed, you expect it if you are a woman on the right or any place in between.
Cooper spoke with feeling at the Labour women’s conference about the shock she and Kendall felt at finding it in the one place she never expected it: the left, whose decent adherents called them “witches” and “cows” for opposing the great Corbyn.
You can hear the same shock in the voices of other leftwing women: “The Labour party was like my family,” Ayesha Hazarika, a former aide to Harriet Harman, told me.
I knew what she meant.
You had your disagreements, but you kept them within reasonable limits so that relationships were not damaged beyond repair.
Now, to paraphrase George Orwell, the Labour party is a family with delinquent children in control.
Hazarika learned about the new politics when she made the mildest criticism of Corbyn on television.
Her Twitter timeline filled up with insults about her appearance, her dress sense and her hairstyle. “Some people stayed up all night shouting at me.”
A sliver of ice has entered her heart and it will never beat with same warmth when she looks on the Corbyn Labour party again.
As for racism, Corbyn has associated with the worst type of antisemites: Holocaust deniers, men who think Jews made bread from Christian blood or were behind the 9/11 atrocities.
No blood libel was too bloody for them.
He keeps saying he’s not a racist, but he’s happy to keep racist company.
I cannot see how the left can attack Tory racism while he remains leader, although doubtless it will try.
Or indeed attack Tory hypocrisy. Corbyn says he is against abuse “from whatever quarter it comes” and does not want to purge the Labour party.
Yet he never punishes the abusers and warns MPs who defied him on Syria that “there will be “no hiding place”, which sounds like an incitement to purge to them – and to me.
In his Poem to Posterity, Brecht offered an explanation of far left excess and a partial justification for his own support for the crimes of Stalin.
Even the hatred of squalor
Makes the brow grow stern.
Even anger against injustice
Makes the voice grow harsh. Alas, we
Who wished to lay the foundations of kindness
Could not ourselves be kind.
His lines endure because they acknowledge a truth about political commitment.
Brecht understood that the certainty of your virtue will lead you into cruelty.
Left-wing men can treat women appallingly and left-wing agitators can mimic the language and tactics of the far right.
They are so convinced of their righteousness they cannot admit their faults.
Leftists would behave better if they stopped acting like teenage vegetarians and found the honesty to acknowledge their kinship with the rest of compromised humanity.
The Corbyn generation shows no sign of doing it. And it ought to be obvious by now that Labour people will be their targets.
Brecht’s communists spent as much time fighting social democrats as Nazis in the 1930s.
The Corbynites’ real enemies are not Tories, whom they rather respect for standing up for the interests of their class, but Labour MPs who fail to show the required radical virtue and betray the left-wing cause.
They don’t mutter darkly that there will be “no hiding place” for Tory MPs who voted in favour of bombing Isis.
They don’t scream that Conservative women are “witches” and “cows”.
They don’t deliver death threats to David Cameron.
Their virtuous hatred is righteously reserved for their own side and its ugliness will destroy the myth of leftwing decency more thoroughly than the right ever could.